“Being Quiet is Useful”
Socio-cultural Perspectives on Silence in Ancient Egyptian Wisdom Literature
(Dr Ilaria Cariddi, Università degli Studi di Firenze)
(Dr Ilaria Cariddi, Università degli Studi di Firenze)
In the long history of the so-called “wisdom” genre of ancient Egyptian literature, one of the most recurring topoi is the advice of keeping silence—(s)gr—a virtue deemed essential for social coexistence, presented as a solution of daily-life issues, and as a means to reach personal success.
Far from advocating submissiveness, or a dismissal of discourse, for the Egyptians “being silent” meant mastering every aspect of the difficult art of conversation, as “speech is similar to fire”: refraining from speaking can be a form of prudence, respect, self-control, and of conflict management. Judicious and morally superior, the “silent man” is also capable of preventing those conducts that hinder social interactions—and, later on, also considered offensive to the gods: calumny, hypocrisy, excessive criticism, chattery, verbal violence.
Various textual sources concur in presenting silence as a quality admired by the community, crucial in courtly behaviour, and rewarded by the sovereign. From the New Kingdom onwards, it also subsumes the principle of a reverential quiet in the human-divine relationship.
The presentation will offer a selection of quotes from the classics of the genre, in order to discuss the development of a concept that appears peculiar in the ancient Mediterranean landscape of ethics.